Christmas Cocktails at Home: Eggnog, a Poinsettia, Two Classics and Zero-Proof Picks

Christmas is the one time of year when a little ceremony around drinks feels right: a pitcher of homemade eggnog, something sparkling when the family arrives, a stirred drink by the tree after dinner. None of it needs a professional bar. With a short menu, a few tools and some prep the day before, you can make drinks that feel special and still spend the evening with your guests.

These recipes are for adults 21 and over. Every list below also includes something good for guests who don’t drink, because a festive glass shouldn’t depend on what’s in it.

Plan a short Christmas drink menu

The easiest way to host is to pick three drinks and do them well:

  • One make-ahead drink that waits in the fridge, like eggnog.
  • One sparkling drink for arrivals and toasts.
  • One stirred or creamy drink for after dinner.

Then add at least one zero-proof drink that’s just as pretty as the rest. If you’re not sure how many bottles to buy, our guide to how much alcohol to buy for a party walks through the math, and our holiday party bartending post covers batching and self-serve stations.

Homemade eggnog (cooked, so it’s safe)

Traditional eggnog uses raw eggs. The FDA’s egg safety advice is to cook dishes containing eggs to 160°F, or to use pasteurized eggs or egg products in recipes served raw. A cooked custard base solves that and tastes rich and smooth.

Makes about 6 servings

  • 2 cups whole milk
  • 1 cup heavy cream
  • 4 large eggs
  • 1/2 cup sugar
  • 1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • A pinch of salt and a pinch of cinnamon
  • Fresh nutmeg for grating
  1. Warm the milk, cream, cinnamon and salt in a saucepan until steaming. Don’t let it boil.
  2. In a bowl, whisk the eggs and sugar until pale.
  3. Slowly whisk about a cup of the hot milk into the eggs, then pour everything back into the pan.
  4. Cook over low heat, stirring constantly, until a thermometer reads 160°F and the mixture coats the back of a spoon.
  5. Strain into a jug, stir in the vanilla and chill for at least four hours.

To serve, pour about 4 oz of eggnog into a small glass and grate nutmeg on top. Guests who want a spiked version can add 1 to 1.5 oz of brandy, bourbon or aged rum to their own glass. Keeping the spirit out of the jug means the eggnog itself stays zero-proof and nobody has to guess what’s in it. Keep it in the fridge until serving, and don’t leave it out at room temperature for more than two hours. If you’d rather skip the cooking, store-bought pasteurized eggnog works the same way.

The Poinsettia

A bright, easy sparkler for when people walk in the door.

  • 1/2 oz orange liqueur
  • 1 oz cranberry juice
  • About 4 oz chilled sparkling wine

Add the orange liqueur and cranberry juice to a flute, then top slowly with sparkling wine. Garnish with a few fresh cranberries or a strip of orange peel. For more sparkling ideas, see our New Year’s Eve drinks post.

Cinnamon Old Fashioned

A warm-spiced version of the classic that suits a cold evening.

  • 2 oz bourbon or rye
  • 1/4 oz cinnamon syrup
  • 2 dashes aromatic bitters
  • Orange peel

Stir the whiskey, syrup and bitters with ice in a mixing glass for about 20 seconds, then strain over a large cube in a rocks glass. Express the orange peel over the top and drop it in. Clear, slow-melting ice makes a real difference here; our guide to ice molds shows how to make it.

Brandy Alexander

A creamy, chocolate-and-nutmeg after-dinner drink that tastes like dessert.

  • 1 1/2 oz brandy or cognac
  • 1 oz dark crème de cacao
  • 1 oz heavy cream

Shake hard with ice and strain into a chilled coupe. Grate a little nutmeg on top. Creamy drinks hide their strength well, so make them small.

Two zero-proof Christmas drinks

Pomegranate ginger fizz

  • 2 oz pomegranate juice
  • 1/2 oz fresh lime juice
  • About 4 oz ginger beer

Build over ice in a tall glass and garnish with a lime wheel and a few pomegranate seeds.

Spiced orange spritz

  • 2 oz fresh orange juice
  • 1/4 oz cinnamon syrup
  • Soda water to top

Stir the juice and syrup over ice, top with soda water and add an orange slice. Serve both in the same glassware as the cocktails so nobody feels singled out. Our zero-proof holiday drinks post has more ideas.

Add a festive sugar rim

A sugar rim turns a simple sparkler into a party drink. Run an orange or lime wedge around half the rim of the glass, then roll the outside edge in sugar mixed with a little orange zest or cinnamon. A shallow dish makes this tidy, and rimming only half the glass lets guests choose. Rim glasses an hour ahead and keep them upright so the sugar sets.

Host safely

Holiday hosting means looking after your guests as well as their glasses:

  • Serve alcohol only to adults 21 and over.
  • Know what’s in a drink. NIAAA defines a U.S. standard drink as about 0.6 fluid ounces of pure alcohol, the amount in 1.5 oz of 80-proof spirits or 5 oz of table wine. A drink with 2 oz of whiskey is more than one, so measure with a jigger rather than free-pouring.
  • Put out food and water from the start.
  • Plan rides home, and stop serving well before the party ends. Warm cider or cocoa is a good last round; our warm winter drinks bar post shows how to set one up.

Our picks

For the cinnamon drinks

Liber & Co. Cinnamon Syrup is a cane-sugar syrup made with cinnamon bark, ready to use in the Old Fashioned and the zero-proof spritz above.

For neat sugar rims

This hand-painted Mexican glass rimmer is a ceramic rimming dish made by hand in Guerrero, Mexico, and looks good left out on a holiday bar.

For the basic tools

The Vibhsa four-piece bar tool set (silver) covers a shaker, a jigger, a stirring spoon and an opener. Our home bar essentials guide explains what else is worth having.

Shop the gear

Please drink responsibly; alcohol is for adults 21 and over.

FAQ

Can I make eggnog ahead of time?

Yes. Make it the day before and keep it in the fridge; the FDA says to use refrigerated cooked egg dishes within 3 to 4 days. Stir before serving.

What’s the easiest Christmas cocktail for a crowd?

The Poinsettia. It takes seconds per glass, and you can pre-mix the cranberry and orange liqueur in a pitcher.

What can I serve guests who don’t drink?

Plain eggnog, the pomegranate ginger fizz or the spiced orange spritz, served in the same glasses as everyone else’s drinks.

We run the NicheStuff store; some links in this post go to products we sell.

Top image: Glass of eggnog with cinnamon 01, Wheeler Cowperthwaite, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.